Fourth-placed Atlético received about €68m more than third-placed Girona
Girona finished third in La Liga in 2023/24, one place above Atlético de Madrid. Going by the table, you would expect Girona to have taken more of the TV money. It was the other way round.
In the 2023/24 distribution figures La Liga published on 18 December 2024, Atlético received €117.89m and Girona €49.80m after the LaLiga Impulso adjustments (the deal with CVC approved by the clubs' general assembly), a gap of about €68.09m. For two clubs one place apart, that is a lot of money.
The distribution rules show how the order can flip. Spain's Royal Decree-Law 5/2015 (Real Decreto-ley 5/2015) splits half of the top flight's share equally among the 20 clubs, and even the part paid on sporting results is worked out over the last five seasons. The rest depends on gate revenue and each club's contribution to the TV product, so the amount decided by a single season's finishing position is smaller than most people assume.
League position decides a quarter of the top-flight share
Under Article 5(2) of the decree, revenue from the league's broadcast rights is first split 90% to the top division and 10% to the second. Article 5(3) says that, of the top division's share, 50% is divided equally and the other 50% is split evenly between sporting results and what the law calls implantación social, roughly a club's social reach. Each of those two pots is worth 25% of the top division's share.
The equal half pays the same to a big club and to a newly promoted one. Only the 25% for results depends on league position, and even that is not settled by one season.
Results money is based on five seasons
The decree calculates the top division's results money over the last five seasons. The pot is first allocated across those seasons: 35% to the most recent, 20% to the one before and 15% to each of the three before that. Each season's slice is then divided by finishing position, using percentages written into the decree: 17% for first, 15% for second, 13% for third, 11% for fourth and 9% for fifth, falling two points a place to 5% for seventh, then 3.5% for eighth and steps of 0.25 to 0.5 points from ninth down to 0.25% for 20th.
Across the five seasons from 2019/20 to 2023/24, Atlético finished third, first (champions), third, third and fourth: always in the top four, with one title. Girona finished fifth in the second division, fifth again, sixth (promoted through the play-offs), tenth in La Liga and then third. They spent three of those five seasons in the second tier.
The published figures do not show which five seasons were used for the 2023/24 payout. If it was the five listed above, the third place carried 35% of the weighting, and 45 of the remaining 65 points belonged to seasons Girona spent in the second division.
Either way, the results money is weighted across the last five seasons, so one good season does not wipe out the gap built up before it. The flip side is that a club that has been near the top for years keeps its good finishes in the results calculation for a while after one weaker season.
The last 25% is paid on gate revenue and TV measures
For the remaining 25%, the social-reach money, Article 5(3)(b) 2.º bases one third on average season-ticket and gate revenue over the last five seasons, and two thirds on each club's "contribution to generating income from the commercialisation of television broadcasts".
In 2023/24 Atlético's Civitas Metropolitano held about 70,460 and Girona's Estadi Montilivi about 14,600, so Atlético's ground was roughly 4.8 times the size. The distribution, though, uses five seasons of gate revenue and separate TV measures, so the difference in stadium size does not translate directly into the difference in payouts.
The detail of the TV-related two thirds comes from criteria approved by the top-flight clubs, not from the decree itself. Under the criteria approved on 4 August 2023, part of it is paid on audience figures and the rest is tied to how far each club voluntarily cooperates with measures to improve the broadcast, with audience figures also taken into account there. For 2023/24, exceptional social-reach criteria agreed in June 2022 because of Covid also applied.
Because the equal share is identical, the statutory gap between the two clubs comes from the results money and the social-reach money. The figures compared above, however, are after the LaLiga Impulso adjustments. Before them, Atlético were on €120.10m and Girona on €50.74m, a gap of about €69.36m. The published figures do not show how much of the gap came from each component.
A tough system for clubs new to the top places
If single-season results counted for more, Girona might have cashed in on their breakthrough straight away and used the money to keep key players or strengthen the squad. Under the current system, one good season is spread across the results money of several seasons.
For established clubs it smooths out the results money. After years near the top, one poorer season does not wipe the earlier finishes from the calculation. A club that has only just broken into the top places, on the other hand, struggles to close the results-money gap to the established sides quickly, whatever it does on the pitch.
The system has its logic. Clubs that have drawn big crowds for years and are known well beyond Spain are one factor in the value of the league's rights. On those terms, rewarding sustained results and popularity makes sense.
Still, putting Atlético and Girona side by side for 2023/24 shows that La Liga's distribution is built in favour of clubs that stay near the top. Girona finished third, but their payout that season was only the 11th largest among the 20 top-flight clubs.