In the 13 seasons from Diego Simeone’s arrival in 2011-12 through 2023-24, Atlético de Madrid never finished lower than fifth in La Liga. In that time they won the league twice and reached two Champions League finals. Still, if you had to sum the club up in a few words, “horrible to play against” fits better than “strong”.
Being strong is part of why they are unpleasant to face, of course. But that is true of every strong side. Against Atlético, opponents struggle to move the ball forward easily and find it hard to play the game at their own rhythm.
Atlético’s strength is often put down to fight and spirit. That isn’t wrong, but it doesn’t stop at feelings. Simeone himself has said he wanted a team opponents would find awkward. That way of playing overlaps with the defiance this club has long talked about, and seeing where it overlaps means going back to what Atlético have been proud of.
Atlético have never told their story through winning alone
Words like gritty and unrewarded have long been used about Atlético, rather than elite or authority.
The nickname Colchonero is a case in point. It comes from the red-and-white stripes looking like the pattern on a mattress cover (the full story is in “The Origin of Colchonero”), and it is hardly a polished name. Atlético supporters have called themselves by it all the same.
The club’s place within Madrid was distinctive too. Real Madrid have been talked about as the side of success, and Atlético at times as the side carrying defeats and bad luck. It is a simplified picture, and it never matched reality exactly. Still, the idea of Atlético as “not the fortunate ones” links up with the story of El Pupas.
In colloquial Spanish, a pupas is someone dogged by bad luck. President Vicente Calderón used the word in 1966, about the club’s stadium by the Manzanares. In the European Cup final of 15 May 1974, Bayern Munich equalised at the very end of extra time to make it 1-1. After that first final, defender José Luis Capón is reported to have said in the dressing room, “Somos el Pupas. Mucha razón tiene nuestro presidente” (we are El Pupas; our president is quite right). Atlético lost the replay 4-0 two days later. The president and the player were both insiders, and the name has followed Atlético ever since.
The name never became just a way of laughing at weakness. Atlético have been through lean spells many times, and those years are still told as part of the club’s history.
Getting through hard spells is talked about as part of Atlético’s character
Controlling a match and making the opponent follow your plan is an attractive kind of strength. With Atlético, the picture handed down as part of the club’s character is of a team holding out while pinned back and not giving the opponent an easy time even when a match is going badly.
The phrase that sums this up is Coraje y Corazón (courage and heart). It is in the lyrics of the club anthem and has been used in the club’s official messaging too. You can hear it as a rallying cry, but it reads better as a description of not abandoning your way of playing when things get hard.
With those words in mind, you can see something similar in the way Atlético take away the opponent’s strengths and pick up the result. Some Atlético wins are less comfortable than the final score might suggest. Before showing what they do well, they go after what you do well. Atlético’s unpleasantness looks of a piece with what has long been described as the club’s character.
Simeone made an awkward team into a weekly way of playing
In a 2016 interview, Simeone said that from the start he had insisted on being an awkward team for opponents. He has also rejected the defeatism tied to El Pupas, saying in effect that he does not live with that kind of negativity. He did not simply turn the self-image he inherited into tactics.
All the same, a team that keeps fighting stronger opponents overlaps in places with the defiance this club has long talked about. Simeone made that approach something the team can reproduce every week, through defensive principles and match management.
The result became known as Cholismo. A common image of Cholismo is a deep 4-4-2, and closing the middle, moving across as a unit and attacking quickly after winning the ball is one of the ways of playing that came to stand for it. Formation and line height alone don’t explain it, though.
At its centre is not letting the opponent have an easy time. The middle is hard to get into, and a team pushed wide still gets no freedom out there. Once Atlético win the ball, the opponent gets no time to regroup, and the tempo is dragged down to Atlético’s pace. Each of these things is unspectacular on its own, but kept up over 90 minutes they can wear the other side down.
This way of defending does not depend much on how fired up the team is on the day. So Atlético are not only dangerous on days when they are inspired. Playing as normal, they can still turn the game into a slog for the other side.
Atlético have added more ways to make life difficult
Recent Atlético sides are harder to explain with the image of a team that sits deep and holds on.
They haven’t become a different team, but they have more tools. Early Cholismo is remembered for closing the middle and attacking quickly, yet even then the team used a high press and adjusted its shape. More recently, keeping the ball to run the game and moving players around in attack have become more noticeable. They also switch between a deep block and a high press from match to match.
There are matches where they sit deep and matches where they come at you high, spells where they have the ball and spells where they leave it to you. With that many options, preparing for one thing is often not enough.
Losing finals did not break Atlético’s story
What makes this club hard work isn’t only visible when they are winning. Sometimes it shows more clearly when they lose.
Lisbon, the 2014 Champions League final. Atlético were 1-0 up going into the 93rd minute, moments from becoming European champions. Sergio Ramos then headed the equaliser, and Atlético lost 4-1 after extra time. Two years later in Milan, they lost to the same Real Madrid on penalties. The name El Pupas was brought up again.
Atlético did not stop at Lisbon. Two years after losing the 2014 final to Real Madrid, they reached the Champions League final again. On that occasion at least, the defeat did not end their challenge.
At Atlético, the memory of going unrewarded and of falling one step short is already part of the club’s story. That is not the same as celebrating defeat, but one defeat does not easily break that story.
Atlético’s way of playing looks close to the defiance the club has long talked about
Atlético de Madrid narrow the opponent’s room to play its own way and pull the match onto their terms. Not every game is glamorous, but the refusal to give the opponent an easy time is what makes this club so awkward.
Simeone built the competitiveness that makes life hard for opponents into a way of playing the team can keep up week after week. That way of playing looks close to the defiance this club has long talked about.