Between 2001 and 2018, Barcelona paid around €7.3 million to José María Enríquez Negreira, a former vice-president of the CTA (the Technical Committee of Referees), and to companies linked to him. On 28 October 2025, a Barcelona court ordered the club, already under investigation in the case, to appear as an investigated party on 27 January 2026. Distrust of Spanish refereeing is now dealt with in a courtroom as well as shouted from the stands.
This piece is not about the Negreira case itself. It is about how La Liga's referees are assessed. Since the summer of 2025, the way referees are graded, the way their decisions are explained in public, who runs VAR and the terms they work under have all changed, and these changes have received relatively little attention in Japan. Criticism of referees lands better when you know how the system works.
From 2026-27, referee assessment is built around video analysis
La Liga referees are graded match by match, and those grades feed into appointments and end-of-season promotion and relegation. Up to 2025-26, the main input was the report of a CTA assessor (oficial informador) in the stadium. In the reshuffle before 2026-27, four referees joined the top-flight list and four left it. Two of the four who left stopped refereeing on the pitch and moved to full-time VAR duty.
AI has already been postponed once. Mundo Deportivo (4 August 2025) reported that from 2025-26 AI analysis would account for roughly 30 per cent of the grade, focusing mainly on the accuracy of foul and yellow-card decisions. On 19 November 2025 the same paper reported that there would be no AI that season after all, and the CTA's revised Circular No. 4 (3 March 2026) folded the AI share back into the human assessment because the tool could not be developed in time.
Circular No. 3 for 2026-27 (11 August 2026) changes the weighting substantially. For referees and assistants, 65 per cent of the grade now comes from a TV Observer who reviews the whole match on video, 25 per cent from a coach in the stadium and 10 per cent from the CTA's view of the full season. The TV Observer has to base the grade on incidents and data flagged by AI tools, but a person still gives the final mark. There are fewer assessors in the stadium, and their role has moved towards coaching. For VAR officials, 55 per cent of the grade is "reliability": how many on-field reviews and relevant checks they got right or wrong. That item was already part of the 2025-26 criteria.
In the summer of 2025 the CTA also set up an Expert Committee (Comisión de Expertos) to discuss how referees are graded and appointed and how AI should be used. Its members are Sevilla FC (as the club representative), former Spain striker Álvaro Negredo, three former referees (Bernabé, Lesma López and Marcos Álvarez) and former coach José Ángel "Cuco" Ziganda.
With Tiempo de Revisión, the CTA admits its own mistakes
Three matchdays into 2025-26, on 11 September 2025, the CTA released the first episode of "Tiempo de Revisión". Each episode replays notable decisions and explains whether they were right; in 2025-26 the presenter was CTA spokesperson Marta Frías. Mistakes are called mistakes. The CTA described the initiative as unprecedented ("inédita").
In 2025-26 the incidents were chosen by an advisory panel of former managers José Luis Oltra, José Ramón Sandoval and José Luis Sánchez Vera and former Spain international Fernando Morientes. By 10 March 2026, 24 episodes had been released. From 2026-27, LaLiga's AI system picks the most relevant incidents of each matchday. The CTA can add an extra incident for teaching purposes, but it cannot drop any incident the AI has chosen.
Other transparency measures have arrived around the same time. Since the Supercopa de España in January 2024 and Matchday 20 of that league season, the conversation between referee and VAR has been published for incidents that went to an on-field review (OFR). Appointments used to be published for a whole matchday several days in advance; since 2025-26 each match's officials have been named the day before, by 4 p.m. Referees are also no longer known by both surnames: "Gil Manzano" is now "Jesús Gil", first name and first surname. The CTA calls this "humanising" (humanizar) referees.
Apart from the VAR audio, all of this began after Fran Soto became CTA president in July 2025. His predecessor, Medina Cantalejo, was removed along with most of the leadership, and Soto is still in charge in 2026-27. Soto took over in July 2025 and Tiempo de Revisión started that September. On 28 October the court decided to summon Barcelona, already under investigation, as an investigated party. The Negreira case has been before the courts since 2023, and the timeline alone does not show whether it led to the refereeing reforms.
VAR now has a specialist group of officials
La Liga used to have referees who took charge of matches on the pitch working as VAR in other matches. In 2025-26 the CTA set out to separate on-field and VAR roles and created VAR-PRO, a group of 15 specialist VAR officials covering the first and second divisions. Active on-field referees still went into the VAR room as AVAR (assistant VAR) in some matches that season. Appointments are meant to reflect record and form.
Lower down, another experiment is under way. FVS (Football Video Support) is a simplified, FIFA-approved form of video review, introduced in Liga F (the women's top flight) and Primera Federación (the third tier) in 2025-26. Its main difference from VAR is the coach's challenge: each coach can ask for a video review up to twice a match and keeps the challenge if the decision is overturned.
Nobody has decided to bring a coach's challenge to La Liga. As experience with FVS builds up in Liga F and Primera Federación, the idea may come up for the top flight too.
Referees now have a collective agreement to 2030
The first collective agreement for referees in Spanish men's professional football was concluded by the negotiating committee on 20 February 2026, and the RFEF and AESAF (the Spanish Football Referees' Association) held the formal signing on 9 March. It covers better insurance, protection during illness or injury, and training for life after refereeing through the RFEF's La Academia and LaLiga Business School. LaLiga president Javier Tebas took part in the talks but, in his words, "con voz, pero sin voto" (with a voice but no vote); the agreement was signed by the RFEF and AESAF. It ran only to the end of 2025-26. A second agreement, covering 1 July 2026 to 30 June 2030, was concluded on 29 July 2026.
AI-assisted grading, a public review programme, a specialist VAR group, a coach's challenge in the lower leagues and a labour agreement: apart from the VAR audio, which began in 2024, all of it started or took shape from the summer of 2025. That is a lot of change in a short time. How much the old system needed fixing, and whether the reforms improve the decisions, will only become clear from how they work in practice.
The second part, "They Still Won't Go to the OFR", looks at the contradictions in the system: why VAR holds back from intervening, the uneven way errors are acknowledged, and Atlético de Madrid's own two-sided position.