Through Matchday 25 of 2025-26, BeSoccer counted, club by club, the decisions the CTA had admitted were wrong in its "Tiempo de Revisión" programme (February 2026). Rayo Vallecano came off worst with four. Celta and Espanyol had two each. On the other side, Atlético de Madrid and Barcelona had each gained twice.

La Liga has a system for grading referees and formally admitting their mistakes. As the first part of this series explained, a public review programme, a dedicated VAR panel and a labour agreement for referees have all arrived since the summer of 2025 (the RFEF had also announced plans to look at using AI in referee grading).

Errors can be corrected during a match through VAR. The VAR checks incidents involving goals, penalties, straight red cards and mistaken identity, and when it sees a clear error it recommends a review to the referee. That recommendation is what is usually called a VAR intervention. Only the referee can start a review. The trigger is normally the VAR's recommendation, but the referee can also start one if he suspects something serious has been missed. In an OFR the referee watches the footage on the pitchside monitor and makes the final decision, which can mean keeping the original call. For factual decisions such as an offside position, the usual route is a VAR-only review, in which the referee decides on the VAR's information without going to the monitor. So whether a referee goes to the monitor mostly depends on whether the VAR recommends a review first.

The reported two-corrections rule risks making VAR reluctant to intervene

For 2025-26 the CTA said VAR should step in only for clear and manifest errors (error claro y manifiesto). The idea was to return VAR to its role as support for the referee, which fits IFAB's principles.

The grading side came out on "El Partidazo de COPE" in February 2026. According to COPE journalist Isaac Fouto, the CTA works to a standard under which "if the VAR intervenes on a referee twice in a match, that referee is sanctioned." In Fouto's reading, the CTA wants as little VAR involvement as possible. A referee who shows a straight red on his own judgement is rated highly. One who shows a yellow and then changes it to a red after a VAR intervention has that counted as an "error", and two errors put him in "la nevera", the fridge, meaning no match appointments. Fouto also said five referees had been in the fridge the previous weekend. The example he held up was Díaz de Mera's red card for Pathe Ciss in Real Madrid v Rayo Vallecano, given without a review and, by his account, rated highly inside the CTA.

If this standard is applied in practice, VAR officials may hesitate to intervene because of the effect on the referee. If, as Fouto described, a VAR correction counts as an error against the referee, recommending a review on a borderline call could affect the referee's mark. Whether VAR officials actually hold back cannot be confirmed from public information.

The admitted errors are few, but they weigh differently depending on the match

In that tally, Rayo had four decisions go against them, Celta and Espanyol two each, and Real Madrid and Barcelona one each. Atlético and Barcelona had two each in their favour. The figures only cover plays the programme chose to review, and every number is small.

The first case that went Atlético's way came against Alavés on 30 August 2025. Giuliano Simeone's seventh-minute opener should have been ruled out for offside. The goalkeeper came out to block the first shot, there were two rebounds before Giuliano put it in. The CTA said Giuliano's offside position had been missed. Offside position is a factual decision, so the goal could have been ruled out through a VAR-only review, without the referee going to the monitor. The VAR, Pablo González Fuertes, was taken off his next appointment as assistant VAR for Real Madrid v Mallorca.

The second came against Rayo at the Metropolitano on 24 September 2025. Koke grabbed goalkeeper Augusto Batalla by the neck and the referee showed a yellow card. The CTA later admitted it should have been a red card. A straight red is something VAR can recommend a review for. Had Koke been sent off there and then, it would very likely have affected his availability for the Madrid derby three days later (Matchday 7). As it was, he only got a yellow and started the derby.

These numbers cannot show deliberate bias towards any club. Even so, one error does not weigh the same in every match. In Koke's case, a player who might otherwise have missed the derby played in it.

Club complaints do not change results

On 3 February 2025 Real Madrid sent the RFEF a formal complaint about the refereeing in their match at Espanyol two days earlier. They asked for the VAR audio of two incidents to be handed over immediately and wrote that what happened went beyond any margin of human error or refereeing interpretation. On 17 February club executives listened to the audio at RFEF headquarters and met the then CTA chief, Medina Cantalejo. In September 2025 the club announced on its own TV channel that it would file a formal complaint with FIFA about the refereeing it had suffered in Spain.

Barcelona wrote to the RFEF on 14 February 2026, two days after the Copa del Rey semi-final first leg at the Metropolitano, which Atlético won 4-0. The letter went beyond that one match. It pointed to inconsistent refereeing criteria across the season and asked for all VAR audio to be published, whether or not there had been an on-field review. Real Madrid had sent a similar letter in February the year before.

After a match, the CTA sometimes admits errors or changes officials' appointments. David Gálvez Rascón, the VAR in Girona v Barcelona who missed Echeverri's foul on Koundé, was reported to have been taken off appointments, and Daniel Jesús Trujillo, the VAR in Real Madrid v Real Sociedad, to have been moved to assistant VAR. Whether the CTA has any duty to answer club complaints, or a deadline for doing so, cannot be confirmed from public information. And no complaint overturns a decision after the fact.

Atlético are among the clubs that gained from admitted errors

Diego Simeone has also faced questions about refereeing controversies at press conferences.

On 24 January 2024 he spoke the day before a Copa del Rey quarter-final against Sevilla. The VAR audio from Real Madrid v Almería had just been published, and the leak of another clip was causing a stir. Simeone said: "The VAR improves them, but at the same time exposes them. That's the reality." He went on that what mattered was what happened rather than what got leaked, "but they think we're all fools. That's what makes me angry" (ESPN, 24 January 2024).

A year later, on 17 January 2025, at his press conference before a league match at Leganés, the talk was about the refereeing in Real Madrid's Copa del Rey tie with Celta the previous night. Simeone said he had not watched the game, that the incidents he had been told about were the kind that had been happening for a hundred years, and that he did not know what surprised people (EFE, 17 January 2025). The answer seemed to suggest that refereeing going Real Madrid's way was nothing new.

In 2025-26, though, the CTA's own admitted errors put Atlético near the top of the clubs that gained. Giuliano's offside goal and the yellow card when Koke grabbed Batalla by the neck were both admitted as errors, and both helped Atlético. For the team of a coach who has spoken out about refereeing, those are uncomfortable numbers.

The same goes for other clubs. One matchday Atlético gain, another Rayo lose. The pattern of admitted errors does not point to anyone targeting a particular club. Uncorrected errors can hit any club.

Post-match reviews feed into referees' grades, but decisions are not changed after the fact

Making refereeing decisions public has moved forward. VAR audio has been published since January 2024, and Tiempo de Revisión, the dedicated VAR panel and the referees' labour agreement have all arrived since the summer of 2025. After a match, the CTA can review errors and reflect them in the officials' grades and appointments. That does not change the decision in question after the fact. During the match, decisions can be corrected through VAR checks and reviews, either an OFR at the monitor or a VAR-only review in which the referee decides on the VAR's information. If the reported two-corrections rule is in effect, the grading that follows a match could become a reason for VAR to hold back from recommending a review during one.

Today's Cholismo Practice
When an OFR you expected never comes, check whether that matchday's Tiempo de Revisión picks the play up. Setting the plays the CTA admits were wrong against the ones it leaves out gives you something concrete when you ask why VAR stayed out.
Share